Pages

Showing posts with label Article 23 Security Bill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article 23 Security Bill. Show all posts

Wednesday, 28 March 2012

No honeymoon for HK chief executive-elect who takes office 1st July

Henry Tang outs CY Leung on 2003 Article 23 protest - State secret revealed live on TV

The Cosa Nostra has a drop-dead principle of “Omerta” – under no circumstances – even threat of death, can a member squeal on the brotherhood. Too many dead bodies, too many factions, too much money, hundreds of lucrative franchises at stake for drugs, money-laundering, arms trafficking, white slavery plus strategic agents planted in police forces and parliaments everywhere.

The obsessively opaque Chinese Communist Party has a similar unforgiving code on State Secrets. The very survival of the party depends on it.

Zhao Ziyang the party secretary-general during the 1989 Tian’anmen crisis was sacked for dissenting on sending tanks to roll over the students. His bigger crime was letting the students know that Old Deng had returned from retirement to take charge and unleash the killing machines.

Zhao had disclosed a State Secret as he tearfully urged the students to vacate the square to avert the impending massacre. “I have come too late” was his lament. Zhao Ziyang was expelled from the party, held under house arrest till death and denied a state funeral.

Henry Tang reveals a State Secret. And goes on vacation

Henry Tang wagged an accusatory finger at CY Leung at the final debate between the CE contenders, for urging riot police action to stop the 2003 public march of over half a million residents against the Article 23 Security Bill. 


Not only did Henry disclose a State Secret - he did so on prime-time TV to a stunned Hong Kong audience.

“I heard what you said with my own ears” thundered Tang, for once transcending his silly public grin. He was genuinely angry and indignant. That sealed his fate with the party bosses in Beijing – and added credence to persistent rumours of CY Leung’s underground communist status and jackboot tendencies.



CY Leung denied that he urged truncheons, tear gas, pepper-spray or water cannons be used on the marchers. Confident that executive council minutes only record points of agreed action and not verbatim accounts, CY even pledged to release relevant minutes to “clear the allegations”.



Tellingly, no one else from that fateful executive council meeting stood up for CY Leung or contradicted Henry Tang.


Tang’s disclosure also panicked Madam Regina Ip, another future CE hopeful, who was secretary for security then and has as much to hide about that shameful incident. She was in charge of the uniformed services waiting for the green light. 


The trouble with Article 23


The Article 23 provisions, which resulted in the biggest demonstration in modern Hong Kong history, would have allowed the banning of any organization banned by Beijing - such as Falun Gong for instance - without the HK government having to conduct an independent investigation. It would have allowed the police to conduct warrantless searches at any time, anywhere, of anybody. A sedition provision would give the government power to decide what constitutes provocative speech - written, spoken or delivered on the Internet. It would be a crime to listen to such speech and fail to report it.


Those subject to the law would have been citizens and all permanent residents - no matter where they reside, in or out of the territory. It would have included people who visited or transited through Hong Kong as well. Those violating Article 23 were potentially subject to life in prison.



Henry Tang must thank fate for being a HK citizen under the “One Country, Two Systems” principle. No gang of secret police kicked down his doors to whisk him away in the dead of night to an undisclosed location to be beaten into signing a ‘confession’ or fed mercury-laced food to kill him slowly. His wife and children are not under constant surveillance. No security cameras spy on him. No police thugs squat in unmarked cars both ends of his street. He cannot be ‘disappeared’. In fact the man is leaving for a vacation break in a huff.



Chief Executive-elect dashes to Central Liaison Office



Perhaps decades of regular visits and coaching at the Central Liaison Office have become a fixed routine for CY Leung. His dash there the day after his selection, went down like a lead balloon. It was unseemly and undignified for Hong Kong’s next leader to be running to shadowy minders at the CLO.



He forgot that he was now the leader-elect of Hong Kong. If the Central Liaison Office folk want to see him, surely they can book an appointment at his office? Was he there to thank them for stealing the election for him? Was he grateful they pressured the Select Committee probing his West Kowloon Centre project indiscretion to delay till after 25th March?



Citizens were left wondering whether CY Leung was their chief executive-elect or Beijing’s under-cover mole. The radio waves, talk shows and press were electrified with denunciations. One columnist in the South China Morning Post warned of the ‘long nightmare’ ahead.



Obligation to pass Article 23?



Of all the priorities on the plate of the incoming chief executive, CY unwisely resurrected the dreaded Article 23 to the top of his agenda. He pledged to consult widely for consensus. The message Hong Kong citizens delivered so unequivocally on 1st July 2003 seems not to have registered.



CY risks provoking a Hong Kong already suspicious, wary and angry at the stage-managed, small-circle election and the blatant interference of the Central Liaison Office apparatchiks. They do not trust him or them. The consensus he will find on Article 23 is that Hong Kong citizens do not want it.



They may be denied universal franchise and have unwanted leaders imposed on them but Hong Kong citizens have shown they will stand up for their first world freedoms.



Article 23 has little relevance for security in the territory. External defence and international relations are mandates of the PRC. Article 23 has all the tools for clamping down on rights and freedoms which distinguish the city from the rest of China and much of Asia.



Chinese scholar Wong Yiu-chong analysed the attempt to insert Article 23 into HK’s Basic Law in the Asia Perspective Journal (Kyungnam University, South Korea) as the “Leninist integration” strategy of steady absorption.



Starting with the lowest approval rating



CY Leung will start his term with the lowest votes for any chief executive over the past three Election Committee cycles and the lowest approval ratings for an incoming chief executive. His approval rating at 35% is less than half what his predecessors Tung Chee-hwa and Donald Tsang started with.



Citizens of Hong Kong indicated their rejection of the farcical CE election exercise and all three candidates, by casting a whopping 55% blank protest vote in the mock election organized by the HKU Public Opinion Poll over the two days preceding the Election Committee voting. Those who picked from the three tallied 17.8% for CY Leung, 16.3% Henry Tang and 11.4% Albert Ho.



Despite the online voting computers being hacked and disabled, 223,000 people from all walks of life switched to the inconvenience of queuing to cast paper votes at 15 stations set up for the purpose. The organizers had only expected about 50,000 participants even for the online exercise! That should give the Beijing bosses pause for thought on how deep feelings run in HK.



CY has to be cognizant of the extremely weak position he is starting from. He has already stumbled badly even before he takes office. He cannot be seen as a stooge of the Central Liaison Office. Whether he is a closet communist is beside the point. That is his problem - not Hong Kong’s.



CY Leung will have no ‘honeymoon’ allowance. He has to grow into a true leader of 7 million pro-active citizens quickly or find it impossible to govern. He is too sharp and too diligent to fail so obviously. He may yet prove his critics wrong. The only trajectory available to him is up!



ENDS

Tuesday, 20 December 2011

Article 23 Security Bill slithers below the pretend CE election



A combination photograph shows Hong Kong Chief Secretary Henry Tang (L) at government headquarters September 28, 2011 and Convenor of Hong Kong's Executive Council Leung Chun-ying attending an event September 22, 2011. Both Tang and Leung have announced their resignation, clearing the way for them to contest the Chief Executive election in 2011. Picture taken on September 28, 2011 and September 22, 2011 respectively.
Tycoons' favourite vs Public's choice
What is the agenda of Hong Kong’s 2012 Chief Executive?

Henry Tang has the property tycoons raising toasts to his imminent coronation. CY Leung seems to be blocked out by the moneyed elite. Henry invested in PR minders who 
conjured the non-slogan “We are Tomorrow” not because he was in danger of being rejected but to gain traction on public polls where C Y Leung is enjoying a massive lead.
 
There is greater public support for the candidate the tycoons do not like. The pretend election is already a farce even before it starts. Beijing has so far not overtly declared its preference. It initially found the idea of a competitive ‘election’ of two approved candidates a good diversion from an otherwise even sillier exercise.

Tang’s PR advisors have scheduled a series of photo-ops with actors, chambers of commerce, his alma mater and other friendlies to get him onto the front pages of press and TV news broadcasts. C Y has been doing the rounds of ‘ordinary’ people.

No clear platform from either candidate

Neither candidate is able to articulate a coherent agenda as CE when “elected” by a college of 1,200 functional constituency representatives and pro-Beijing compatriots. That is no surprise as they don’t answer to the people they are supposed to rule. Their agenda will come in a sealed brown envelope from Beijing.

Both candidates reported to the Beijing Liaison Office in the middle of their ‘campaigns’. This was monitored by HK press and widely reported. Tang said he would go if invited and did - a day after he said there was no reason for him to visit the Liaison Office. C Y said it was quite routine and that he had been there many times over the years.

Headmaster sits at Beijing Liaison Office

If HK residents needed any reminder of where power really resides in the SAR, that was it: both CE aspirants seeking approval, providing clarifications and receiving instructions from the Beijing Liaison Office. The headmaster sits there, not in Government House.

The views of 7 million Hong Kong citizens are irrelevant to this closed door, small circle exercise in annointing Beijing’s appointee.

As Beijing has delayed selection of the CE by universal suffrage till 2017, it is watching the process of the people’s will being expressed in opinion polls with some curiosity, alarm and bewilderment. It is said that Communist regimes would rather not rig elections but prefer to ensure their outcomes in advance. Russia was caught with Putin’s ‘United Russia’ ruling party agents rifling the ballot box recently. The mistake lay in getting caught.

Vote-rigging at recent District Board elections

In the District Board elections of November, there were numerous cases of vote-rigging and voter identity falsification, hinting at well organized fraud. There is suspicion that the opaque “underground fronts” may have contributed expertise. Discovery of this activity has made the agents and their sponsors uncomfortable as the HK judicial system has the power to put these criminals in the dock with potentially damaging public disclosures.

The HK administration is leaning backwards. HK press is watching the investigative process unfold with keen interest. The Democratic Party says it has received 800 reports of suspicious voter registration. The Independent Commission Against Corruption has arrested 22 people for corrupt conduct and charged six so far.

HK residents are generally sanguine about matters which are the purview of the civil service, the police and the courts. They trust their institutions of governance. They do not expect to be cheated and lied to. If their trust is betrayed, they can turn surprisingly hostile, as Tung Chee-hwa, the first CE and Regina Ip, then Secretary for Security, discovered when they tried to ram the flawed Article 23 Security Bill into law in 2003.

Time for mandatory voter registration

Because of this relaxed trust in the institutions of government, HK residents do not compulsively register to vote or exercise their right to vote. Societies of free speech, free press and respect for human rights are very fertile grounds for a committed band of organizers to take control by sheer default.

When well funded and driven by dedicated organizers sent from the mainland for ‘united front’ work (as it is euphemistically called) HK faces the prospect of its schools, volunteer groups, youth organizations, charity societies, university bodies, worker unions, District Boards and Legislative Council being taken over by elected, hardworking cadres.

It will be in the interest of the Hong Kong SAR to introduce legislation to make it mandatory for all eligible residents to register and vote in local elections so the community is not politically hijacked by default. This should become a primary objective of the next administration as HK moves to elect its 2017 CE by universal suffrage.

Along with that, legislation should also be introduced for political parties to declare their sources of funding. It will be of interest to know how much money is being channelled to which political party and proxies from which sponsor. It is up to HK citizens to then decide who to vote for.

Under normal circumstances this would be relevant and vital information. However there is considerable fear that retribution will be visited on businessmen and other donors to Democratic parties, so the administration would rather close an eye on the subject. 

Jimmy Lai’s donations to the Democratic & Civic Parties over the years raised considerable noise from the compatriots. The sponsorship from across the border to pro-Beijing parties and front organizations passes without comment.

Whither Article 23 Security Bill?

Buried in all the pseudo-election distraction is the ominous Article 23 Security Bill. If the SAR Legislature does not pass this into law within the life of the 2012 administration, it will be near impossible to pull the trick after 2017. 

There is no public discussion about it. There are fitful rumours about its revival and sundry ‘patriots’ lament its absence. The Macau SAR passed its Security Bill without fuss in 2009. There is agitation on the streets of Macau now for greater democracy - perhaps too late.

Neither Henry Tang nor C Y Leung has declared a clear position on it. When asked, they waffle. Given the unequivocal Hong Kong rejection (in 2003) of an alignment to mainland style criminalization of freedoms of assembly, expression, press and guaranteed human rights, no candidate for CE in 2017 would be elected if his platform compromised the freedoms and rights HK people take for granted.

Chessboard re-arranged. Stephen Lam promoted to Queen

It is not mere coincidence that Secretary for Constitutional &
Mainland Affairs, Stephen Lam Sui-lung, was selected ahead of more suitable policy secretaries, to replace Henry Tang as Chief Secretary to the HKSAR Government. He is a critical piece on the chessboard.
Lam, the most unpopular
Chief Secretary since 1997

In defending Lam’s appointment as Chief Secretary with the lowest public approval rating of any since 1997, Donald Tsang suggested that Lam’s love of Hong Kong is beyond question even if Hong Kong citizens rate him low. Stephen Lam is surprisingly elevated to the most powerful position in HK’s civil service and nobody has explained why. It is a strategically calibrated move.

Lam distinguished himself in his previous position for attempting - without public  consultation - to push a rule that a Legislative Council (LegCo) seat falling vacant due to resignation or death of a sitting member will be immediately replaced, without a by-election, by the candidate who secured the next highest number of votes in the last election!

This situation was forced by the Democrats resigning their seats to protest the continued stalling by the administration for full direct elections by 2012. About half the current LegCo seats are held by nominated ‘Functional Constituency’ representatives from corporate and other entities, many regarded ‘rotten boroughs’ created to stack the pro-Beijing deck.

It is not fanciful to expect the 2012 CE to be tasked with passing the Article 23 into law. Stephen Lam will have a key role there. He will be the lightning rod to draw and earth the disgust of citizens.

The planned next phase of Article 23 is the clear and present danger to Hong Kong.

ENDS

Sunday, 2 October 2011

Bland and Earnest vie for Beijing's nod as next leader of Hong Kong

'Small-circle' Committee to pick Henry or CY Leung

C.Y. Leung, Chairman of Asia Pacific DTZ, at Asia Society New York on September 24, 2010.
CY Leung is a man with a plan
Hong Kong will be given its third Chief Executive since the handover in 1997 of the British territory to the People's Republic of China.  It could be Bland (Henry Tang) or Earnest (CY Leung) in March 2012. The new CE's term will commence 1st July 2012.
Henry waits to be crowned


The right to choose the next Chief Executive is confined to a 1,200 college of  electors which will be in place by December 2011. They represent 0.01 of HK's population. 


Each 'constituency' of this electorate is assigned a fixed number of block votes. Any candidate wishing to be considered for CE has to collect a minimum of 100 nominations.


It is a rubber-stamp assembly to legitimize Beijing's nominee, very much in the mould of politics on the mainland. The 1,200 electors strain keenly for smoke signals from Beijing on whom to vote for. They would rather not back the wrong horse.


The 'small-circle' Election Committee consisted originally of 800 members. In June 2010 legislators voted to increase its size to 1,200 members. This was a concession by Beijing to soften the public ridicule of the process for the most important job in Hong Kong. 


Some members of the pro-democracy camp supported this 'reform' on the understanding that it will be totally abolished by 2017. They want the next CE to be elected by universal suffrage. 


No one is sure if the Election Committee will be disbanded next round as there are mixed signals from the administration and silence from Beijing.


Beijing has been at pains even before 1997 to assure Hong Kong's businessmen that no change will be made to its pro-business policies. 


The 1,200 member CE election committee aggregates chambers of commerce, New Territories villagers, professional bodies, pro-Beijing organizations (NPC deputies, CPPCC members) and other narrow-interest groups. 


Many are known in HK as 'rotten boroughs' created for the purpose of stacking the deck. They have limited self-interest agendas and are easily shown whom to vote for. 


A situation of two CE candidates, both approved by Beijing, is a new one. This will really tax the electors. 


Beijing may eventually wish to harness both in some form, while it gauges both the small-circle and public support for the candidates.


HK citizens locked out of choosing their leader


Hong Kong's 7 million residents are out of the loop. They have to watch in bewilderment as this 'Theater of the Absurd' plays out over the next nine months. In a free election, it is unlikely that either candidate would have a chance of being elected.


The first chief executive, the hapless Tung Chee-hwa had his second term curtailed for failing to push through the infamous Article 23 Security Bill. 


About 500-700,000 Hongkongers from all walks of life poured out on 1st July, 2003 to march peacefully against the Bill. Tung was shell-shocked and his masters in Beijing even more so. It caught all the expert advisers off-guard. 


The outpouring of mass disapproval against this attempt to curb Hong Kong's freedoms of assembly and press, was deeply felt and profound.


ATV, HK's second TV station, has been acquired by mainland owners. Recently the head of RTHK, the public service broadcaster  was replaced by a civil servant with no journalism or broadcast experience. Students at HKU were roughed-up by police with plain-clothes mainland security personnel present during the visit of a high mainland official. 


All these add up to genuine disquiet about the freedoms that Hong Kong residents take for granted.


Hong Kong citizens are additionally facing unaffordable housing, rising inflation, confusion about Cantonese versus English-medium schooling, the depreciating currency (it is pegged to the US Dollar) and policy-paralysis in government. 


They despair over the administration's seeming unwillingness to use its massive foreign reserves and healthy fiscal surplus to address systemic, long-term social problems. 


The administration is pushing to spend billions on a joint bridge infrastructure project with Guangdong Province and to add a third runway to HK international airport, amidst expert misgivings about the need for or commercial viability of these schemes. 


This lopsided prioritization reinforces the long-held suspicion among HK residents of collusion between property developers and bureaucrats, to the detriment of ordinary people.


Hong Kong is a city suffering from prolonged absence of political leadership and a coherent programme. People are weary, impatient and losing faith fast.


Henry Tang (Bland) waits to be appointed CE

Henry Tang Ying-yen is a classic silver-spoon scion of a textile tycoon. His father, Tang Hsiang Chien escaped to Hong Kong from China in 1950 in the aftermath of the 1949 victory of Mao's communist forces and made his fortune as a textile trader. 


HC Tang was subsequently nominated to the standing committee of the Chinese People's Politicial Consultative Conference (CPPCC) which is the advisory body to the nation's legislature, the National People's Congress (NPC). 


The CPPCC was mooted in 1945 to align the Communist Party and the nationalist KMT to a common agenda. When the communists won decisively in 1949, the KMT fled to Taiwan to proclaim the Republic of China (ROC). 


The CPPCC then continued as a nominal advisory body which assembles in Beijing every five years in parallel with the NPC. The NPC approves government budgets and policies.


Henry's 'red' family credentials are well established. The Beijing leadership has been grooming Henry steadily through the senior ranks for ten years. He was initiated into the Tung Chee-hwa administration in July 2002 as Secretary for Commerce, Industry & Technology. 


Henry replaced Antony Leung as Finance Secretary in August 2003 when Leung had to resign for purchasing a Mercedes days before he himself announced a Budget tax increase on cars. 


When Donald Tsang was confirmed as CE in 2005 (after acting as CE from July 2003 when CH Tung resigned), Rafael Hui replaced him as Chief Secretary.  Henry Tang moved into the Chief Secretary's position in 2007 when Rafael Hui retired.


Henry is best known for his impressive cellar of premium Bordeaux and Burgundy wines. His outstanding contribution as financial secretary was to remove the tax on wine. That won him the gratitude of wine consumers, merchants and importers. 


The wine tax abolished in 2008 catapulted Hong Kong beyond London and New York to become the premier wine auction capital of the world. In 2007 the value of wine imported into HK was US$185 million. In 2010 wine import soared to US$858 million - much of that destined for the mainland. 


As with Art Auctions, it is the gush of mainland cash driving the wine auction market. Cynics label this as money laundering with prestige attached.


Given his privileged upbringing, love of fine wine and the lifestyle it connotes, Henry is an affable sort who never needed to cloak-and-dagger his way to the top. 


He treats his associates and subordinates with courtesy and has an easy, relaxed style. The civil service is very comfortable with Henry Tang. He is very much hands-off and let's the bureaucrats get on with their duties without harassment. 


Awkward in public and unable to coherently address unscripted Q&A, Henry comes across as not having his fingers on the pulse of the society he may be called to lead. 


Business tycoons are most comfortable with him. 


CY Leung (Earnest) wants the job, has an agenda


The civil service is wary and nervous of CY Leung. He is the kind of driven boss they dread. Life will not be comfortable for clock-watchers and time-servers under a CY Leung regime.


Unlike Henry, Leung Chun-ying is the son of a policeman. He obtained a diploma in surveying at HK Poly, then went on to Bristol Poly to complete a BA in Real Estate Management.


When he returned to HK, he joined Jones Lang Wooton in 1977. Within 5 years Leung was chairman of its HK Branch, reportedly earning HK$10million. He was admired in local circles as the  "Emperor of the Working Class". 


His colleagues and associates in the real estate business acknowledge his skills, knowledge, leadership and organizational abilities.


He was a former chairman of the HK branch of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors and president of the HK Institute of Surveyors. He has chaired the councils of Lingnan and City Universities.


He served as advisor on land reform to Shenzen, Tianjin and Shanghai municipalities. He is international economic advisor for Hebei province.


It was CY Leung's credentials as a very competent real estate strategist, leader and organizer, which propelled him into the sights of the Communist Party looking for talent in Hong Kong. 


He has been the 'Convenor' of the Unofficial members of the Executive Council (the CE's cabinet) till he resigned in September to stand for CE. Donald Tsang has retained him to help shape his final Policy Address.


CY is best remembered for supporting CH Tung in his 1997 plan to build 85,000 new flats to increase affordable housing stock so that at least 70% of HK residents would be able to afford homes over 10 years. The Home Ownership Scheme (HOS) planned to sell public housing to means-qualified residents at 30-40% below market prices. 


In 2003 the HOS scheme was mothballed by the HK government. Private developers are not supportive of an increased stock of public housing. They are not interested in 70% of the population (nearly 5 million) having access to flats below market prices. 


Two candidates. One almost disinterested.


CY Leung is actively meeting community groups across Hong Kong. He seems to have an appreciation for the plight of the under-class and the widening rich-poor gap. Ordinary people can relate to him. He reaches out. He listens. He takes notes.


Henry is taking the position of an heir waiting to be crowned. He is not going down to interact with society, declare his agenda, solicit support or do any more than wait to be confirmed by Beijing.


CY Leung is the outsider who must generate a wave of popular hope. He badly wants to become the next CE and claims to have an agenda to get HK moving again.


Given the last 15 years of coasting, HK needs bold measures to re-ignite its dynamism. It must deploy its wealth sensibly to make life bearable for the poor and sandwich classes. 


Between the two candidates, CY Leung deserves to be given a chance to show what he can do for Hong Kong. 


However, given Beijing's ear for the business lobby and paranoic fear of 'instability', it may opt for the status-quo. The minders are sure of Henry. They are not too sure of CY. He thinks too deeply and hath a mean and hungry look.


ENDS